Warming up this winter at Coal Yard Cafe on Ithaca's east hill

January 5, 2016 by Mark H. Anbinder

We can hardly believe it's been over nine years since the drab old Coal Office building on Maple Avenue was converted into a cafe, opening first as the Queen of Tarts. The latest incarnation, the Coal Yard Cafe, offers tempting breakfasts and lunches with lots of comfortable seating.

This fireplace will be popular over the winter!This fireplace will be popular over the winter!If you haven't been by since the Queen of Tarts days, you may be astonished at the roomy new interior, which has counter and stools, plus tables and chairs, and big cushioned armchairs by the cast iron fireplace, in an addition to the building added a few years ago. The kitchen area has been expanded, as well, with a proper stove and plenty of prep space for real cooking.

A sausage, spinach, and gruyere breakfast sandwich on French peasant bread.A sausage, spinach, and gruyere breakfast sandwich on French peasant bread.Each morning, the Coal Yard has coffee and pastries, but also breakfast sandwiches cooked from scratch and served on bagels or, even better, French peasant bread. (Really, they're handmade omelets served on bread.) There are beautiful omelets (not served on bread) made to order, and there are daily breakfast specials such as french toast (made from that same peasant bread) served with real maple syrup and bacon, or sweet potato hash with sausage and fried egg. Breakfast is available through lunch hours.

Fried haddock special with fries and cole slaw.Fried haddock special with fries and cole slaw.At lunchtime, there's a daily soup or two, made from scratch, often with a vegetarian option like creamy butternut squash, or the excellent chicken matzah ball soup. A wide variety of sandwiches and salads is often joined by such lunch specials as beef or mushroom lasagna, chicken parmigiana with pasta, pork souvlaki, or, especially on Fridays, fried haddock. The haddock is both tender and crisp, and served on a roll accompanied by perfect french fries, a bit of fresh cole slaw, and tartar sauce. The "Sloppy Michael" sandwich is the chef's own rendition of Sloppy Joes, and the Bleus Burger is just what it sounds like.

We're now in an era when Gimme! doesn't offer the only freshly roasted local coffee, and the Coal Yard is brewing up freshly ground beans from Seneca Sunrise Coffee in Watkins Glen, like their organic Sumatra roast. 

Plan on spending $5-12 for a meal. Watch the Coal Yard's Facebook or Twitter for daily specials, call them at 607-277-0734, or visit 143 Maple Avenue and tell them you heard about them here.

For more, follow 14850 Dining on Facebook and Twitter.


Wings Over Ithaca


335 Pine Tree Road
East Hill Plaza
Ithaca, NY 14850
Phone: 607-256-9464

Read the review

AGAVA Restaurant


381 Pine Tree Road
Ithaca, NY 14850
Phone: 607-319-4366

Read the review